This Particular Happiness: A Childless Love Story by Jackie Shannon Hollis
Release Date: Oct 1, 2019 by Forest Avenue Press
This is the first piece of creative nonfiction by Forest Avenue Press and I thought it was brilliant. This memoir focuses on themes such as family expectations, relationships, friendships, grief, loss, trauma, personal growth and of course motherhood or lack there of. I thought the perspective shown was important because it wasn’t the usual story where a woman could not get pregnant because of infertility, lack of a partner or by making a firm choice on their own. This memoir is about a woman who chose a life of childlessness because of the love she has for her husband, who firmly did not want children. Ultimately it is a choice that she comes to terms with but getting to that point was filled with a lot of self reflection and growth. We get to explore all the moments in their lives that led up to this choice and how it played out in their relationship. It was a very raw and messy account, which is to be expected with such a life changing decision. There are moments where the author pleads with her husband to change his mind but there are also moments where we see tremendous growth.
Maybe it wasn’t him I’d given up a child for. Maybe it was for me. Leading to this moment, held in the power of love and other possibilities. It was me I owed. To stand up and declare my plans. To not wait for someone else’s approval.
The above quote is in reference to the author wanting to make a career change and spend more time writing and exploring other interests.
What should I call myself? Childless by circumstance, from being with a man who didn’t want children? Or by choice, because I chose him and never chose children? I decided it didn’t matter as long as I defined myself by what I had, rather than what I didn’t have.
I thought the author did a great job showing her struggle of resenting her husband but also realizing the many doors that not being a mother opened up. I think this can only be done by having the necessary time to heal and process such complex emotions.
Mom saying he (Dad) wasn’t fine with my choice really meant she wasn’t fine with it. Maybe she never would be. No matter how old I got, or how happy I was without children, the ache for her approval would always be with me.
In addition to overcoming her own struggle with not having children the author also dealt with a complex relationship with her parents and their expectations of her, which is something so many of us can relate to.
The author and her husband clearly went through difficulties but as their relationship evolved they came to understand each other deeply. Whatever resentment that may have been there for a brief period was replace by this understanding, openness and a beautiful ache.
There are so many ways to be in the world and none of them have to be the expected.
*Thank you to the publisher for providing me with a digital ARC of this book. This in no way impacts my review. All opinions are my own.
Β